Case studies / hammer-feather

The Hammer and the Feather: A Drop on the Moon

2 Aug 1971
The Hammer and the Feather: A Drop on the Moon
S71-43788 (2 Aug 1971) - David Scott watches the hammer and feather fall on the Moon. NASA.

Prediction

Galileo's equivalence principle: in a vacuum, all objects fall at the same rate, whatever their mass or density. The 'density vs air' model predicts the feather should fall slower - but only if there is air to provide the difference.

The test

Apollo 15, astronaut David Scott dropped a hammer and a feather at the same time on the airless Moon, broadcast live on TV. The Moon has no atmosphere, so there is no air to slow the feather - the only variable left is gravity.

The result

The hammer and the feather hit the ground at exactly the same instant. On Earth the same experiment needs a vacuum chamber - and gives the same result.

The reaction

One of the most-watched demonstrations of the Apollo program. It confirmed a 400-year-old prediction (Galileo) from 385,000 km away, on live television, with no way to fake a vacuum.

Why it matters

The vacuum removes the only factor (air) that could make the feather fall slower. When that factor is gone, mass and density don't matter - exactly as the globe model's gravity predicts. A live broadcast from the Moon, which the flat model cannot explain.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia - Apollo 15 (the hammer and feather experiment) [1]
  2. Image - NASA Image Library (S71-43788) [2]